best pizza in westchester county

Best Pizza in Westchester County (according to locals)

Looking for the best places to order pizza in Westchester County? We asked local Westchester residents for their go-to pizza places. Below you will find a list of recommended places to order pizza in Westchester County.

Best Pizza in Westchester

Dobbs Ferry

The Parlor at 14 Cedar Street, Dobbs Ferry, NY. Phone: (914) 478-8200

You’ve got to try the pizza Chef David DiBari’s pizzeria, The Parlor. Get The Lemonator- it’s pizza topped with slices of preserved lemon, smoked scamorza cheese, basil, chili, garlic, and Parmigiano. 

“It’s simple and has elements of Umami.” 

Chef David DiBari


Burrata at 425 White Plains Road, Eastchester, NY. Phone: (914) 337-3700

Must try wood-fired pizza in Eastchester, NY.


Villagio’s at 389 North Central Avenue, Hartsdale, NY. Phone: (914) 949-3427

Stop in for pizza at this neighborhood restaurant in Hartsdale. Try the Meat Lovers Pizza with bacon, sausage, pepperoni!


Silver Lake Pizza at 79 Lake Street, West Harrison, NY. Phone: (914) 328-2326

Try the Grandma pizza at Silver Lake Pizza in Harrison.


Villa Maria Pizza at 6 Chatsworth Avenue, Larchmont, NY. Phone: (914) 834-8134

Some locals believe that Villa Maria has the best pizza in Larchmont. Go try it!


Sal’s Pizzeria at 316 Mamaroneck Avenue, Mamaroneck, NY. Phone: (914) 381-2022

Sal’s Pizzeria has a reputation for the best Sicilian pizza in Westchester County.

Mount Vernon

Johnny’s Pizzeria at 30 West Lincoln Avenue, Mount Vernon, NY. Phone: (914)-668-1957

If you live in Westchester County and have not tried Johnny’s Pizzeria yet, you are missing out! Johnny’s is known for its legendary pizza in Westchester County.

North White Plains

Gianfranco Ristorante and Pizzeria at 88 Virginia Road, North White Plains, NY. Phone: (914) 682-5655

Gianfranco is known for it’s Tuna Salad pizza in Westchester County- served cold with tuna salad, lettuce, tomatoes and dressing. Must try their tuna pizza!

New Rochelle

Pizzeria la Rosa at 12 Russel Avenue, New Rochelle, NY. Phone: (914) 633-0800

Local Westchester residents rave about the thin crust pizza at Pizzeria la Rosa. Try their Margherita pizza!


Pelham Pizza at 113 Fifth Avenue, Pelham, NY. Phone: (914) 738-3554

Order any pizza at Pelham Pizza, you can’t go wrong!


Sal’s Pizza and Pasta at 201 Marble Avenue, Pleasantville, NY. Phone: (914) 769-1199

Locals love the cheesy pizza at Sal’s in Pleasantville. Go give it a try!

Pound Ridge

The Inn at Pound Ridge by Jean-Georges at 258 Westchester Avenue, Pound Ridge, NY. Phone: (914) 764-1400

You need to try the Black Truffle and Fontina Pizza at the Inn at Pound Ridge.

best pizza in westchester county
Pizza at the Inn at Pound Ridge

Port Chester

Colony Grill at 35 Abendroth Avenue, Port Chester, NY. Phone: (914) 934-2428

Colony Grill is known of its unique, thin crust pizza. If you haven’t tried the pizza at Colony Grill, you have to try it. Get the Hot Oil Pizza. Kids love the Plain Cheese pizza. The Bacon Pizza is also a hit.

best pizza in westchester county colony grill
Colony Grill Pizza

Rye Brook

Fortina Pizza at 136 South Ridge Road, Rye Brook, NY. Phone: (914) 937-0900

Fortina Pizza has lots of loyal followers in Westchester County. Known for its wood-fired pizza and pasta.


Roma’s Restaurant at 29 Columbus Avenue, Tuckahoe, NY. Phone: (914) 961-3175

Roma’s has a loyal following in Westchester County. They are known for their thin crust pizza.

White Plains

Abatino’s at 670 North Broadway, White Plains, NY. Phone: (914) 686-0380

Get the pan pizza at Abatino’s in White Plains.


Frank Pepe at 1955 Central Park Avenue, Yonkers, NY. Phone: (914) 961-8284

Frank Pepe is a legendary pizzeria from New Haven, CT. Westchester County residents flock to Frank Pepe’s Yonkers location for a taste of the famous Frank Pepe pizza. The White Clam pizza is a must try at Frank Pepe’s.

best pizza in westchester county
Frank Pepe Pizza

You May Also Be Interested in:

Best Pizzas in Connecticut

Best Coffee in Westchester County (according to locals)

Where to go for Hot Chocolate in Westchester County (according to locals)

Chef Peter Kelly’s Favorite Restaurants in Westchester

Where to go for Brunch in Westchester

About Suburbs 101

Suburbs 101 is an insider’s guide to suburban Living. Get the inside scoop on what it’s really like to live in the suburbs through our interviews with local suburbanites and features on Food, Fashion, Home, Garden, Travel, Pets and Local Events. Be sure to Follow Us on Instagram, Like Us on Facebook and subscribe to our Monthly Newsletter.