Best Bakeries in Westchester County 2023 (according to locals)

Do you want to know where to get the best cupcakes in Westchester County? What about the best donuts in Westchester County? What about the best bread in Westchester County?

We asked local Westchester residents for recommendations of bakeries in Westchester. Below is a list of the best bakeries in Westchester County.

Methodology: We asked local residents to give us their recommendations on the best bakeries in Westchester County. This is not a sponsored post. We hope you find this information valuable. We figured the best recommendations are unbiased recommendations from local residents!

Best Bakeries in Westchester County

Best Bakery in Ardsley, NY

The Bakehouse

The Bakehouse at 660 Saw Mill River Rd, Ardsley, NY. Phone: (914) 674-0000

Local Westchester residents go to The Bakehouse for their muffins, tarts and cupcakes. The Bakehouse is a popular bakery in Ardsley with a second location at the Tarrytown train station.

Best Bakery in Armonk, NY

Beascakes Bakery at 575 Main St, Armonk, NY. Phone: (914) 273-3612

Beascakes Bakery is a popular Armonk bakery. It is one of the best bakeries in Westchester County. Locals rave about the donuts and chocolate chip cookies at Beascakes Bakery.

Beascake Bakery best bakery Westchester — Donuts from Beascake Bakery

I’m addicted to the donuts from Beascakes. I’m normally not even a big fan of cake style donuts! My favorite is the strawberry donut.
Westchester Resident

Do you know it costs over $13,000 a month for a family of four to live in Armonk, NY? Check out our Armonk Cost of Living Calculator!

Best Bakery in Chappaqua, NY

Susan Lawrence Gourmet Foods

Susan Lawrence Gourmet Foods at 26 North Greeley Avenue, Chappaqua, NY. Phone: (914) 238-8833

If you are looking for the best cakes in Northern Westchester, Susan Lawrence comes highly recommended by locals.

Best Bakery in Hastings-on-Hudson, NY

By the Way Bakery at 574 Warburton Avenue, Hastings-on-Hudson, NY. Phone: (914) 478-0555

For baked goods that are dairy-free and gluten-free, local Westchester residents go to By the Way Bakery in Hastings-on-Hudson. Their baked goods are also kosher. Note, they are not a nut-free facility.

best bakery in westchester county — Photo Credit: By the Way Bakery

Best Bakery in Mamaroneck, NY

Boiano Bakery

Boiano Bakery at 258 Mamaroneck Ave, Mamaroneck, NY. Phone: (914) 698-2070

For authentic Italian bakeries in Westchester County, locals go to Boiano Bakery in Mamaroneck. Try the cannolis, locals rave about them!

Do you know it costs over $11,000 for a family of four to live in Mamaroneck, NY? Check out our Mamaroneck Cost of Living Calculator

Best Bakery in Mount Kisco, NY

La Tulipe Desserts

La Tulipe Desserts at 455 Lexington Ave, Mt Kisco, NY. Phone: (914) 242-4555

Local Westchester residents rave about the pastries at La Tulipe Desserts. You can’t go wrong with croissants at this French bakery.

Best Bakery in Mount Vernon, NY

Fleetwood Bakery

Fleetwood Bakery at 561 Gramatan Ave, Mt Vernon, NY. Phone: (914) 667-3434

Fleetwood Bakery comes highly recommended by local Westchester residents as one of the best bakeries in Westchester County. Try the cakes at Fleetwood Bakery- you can’t go wrong with the red velvet cake. Locals also rave about the napoleon at Fleetwood Bakery.

Best Bakery in Port Chester, NY

The Kneaded Bread

The Kneaded Bread at 181 N Main St, Port Chester, NY. Phone: (914) 937-9489

For freshly baked bread, local Westchester residents go to The Kneaded Bread in Port Chester. It’s also a great place to grab lunch. Don’t leave without trying their apple pie!

Best Bakery in Rye, NY

The Snackery Bakeshop

The Snackery Bakeshop at 64 Purchase Street, Rye, NY

Although it’s a newcomer in Westchester County, The Snackery has quickly established itself as a favorite bakery in Rye. The Moon Pies are delicious!

Patisserie Salzburg

Patisserie Salzburg at 2 Second Street, Rye, NY

Patisserie Salzburg is one of the best bakeries in Westchester County. Must try- the Almond and Pear Tart.

Do you know it costs over $16,000 a month for a family of four to live in Rye, NY? Check out our Rye Cost of Living Calculator!

Best Bakery in Rye Brook, NY

Cerbone’s Bakery

Cerbone’s Bakery at 140 S Ridge St, Rye Brook, NY 10573. Phone: (914) 937-5474

Cerbone’s is the go-to bakery for local Westchester residents looking for a nut-free bakery in Westchester County. All the baked goods at Cerbone’s are baked in a nut-free facility so there is no fear of cross-contamination. The cupcakes are always a hit at birthday parties- they make one of the best cupcakes in Westchester County!

cerbone's cupcakes — Cerbone’s Bakery (nut-free)

Best Bakeries in Scarsdale, NY

Galloway’s Bakery

Galloway’s Bakery at 69 Harney Rd, Scarsdale, NY. Phone: (914) 725-4074

Local Westchester residents rave about the pies and donuts at Galloway’s Bakery in Scarsdale. Also, do give their strawberry shortcake a try!

Martine’s Fine Bake Shoppe

Martine’s Fine Bake Shoppe at 48 East Pkwy, Scarsdale, NY. Phone: (914) 722-4949

Martine’s is another go-to bakery in Scarsdale. Local Westchester residents recommend the tarts and chocolate chip cookies at Martine’s.

Martine's Bakery — Photo Credit: Martine’s Fine Bake Shoppe

Lulu Cake Boutique

Lulu Cake Boutique at 40 Garth Rd, Scarsdale, NY. Phone: (914) 722-8300

Lulu comes highly recommended by local Westchester residents as a go-to bakery. Lulu is well-known for its cakes.

Do you know it costs over $14,000 a month for a family of four to live in Scarsdale, NY? Check out our Scarsdale Cost of Living Calculator!

Best Bakery in Tuckahoe, NY

Martine’s Fine Bake Shoppe

Martine’s Fine Bake Shoppe at 10 Fisher Ave, Tuckahoe, NY 10707. Phone: (914) 346-8650

Martine’s is a local favorite when it comes to baked goods in Westchester County. The tarts and chocolate chip cookies are highly recommended by local Westchester residents.

Best Bakery in Tarrytown, NY

The Bakehouse

The Bakehouse of Tarrytown at 2 Depot Plaza, Tarrytown, NY 10591. Phone: 914-366-7420

The Bakehouse of Tarrytown is conveniently located at the Tarrytown Metro North train station. This is the sister location of the popular bakery, The Bakehouse in Ardsley. Local Westchester residents recommend the muffins, tarts, and cupcakes.