Top Zagat Rated Restaurants in Westchester

Best Restaurants in Westchester 2022: Top Zagat Rated

Looking for the best restaurants in Westchester County? We asked locals for restaurant recommendations and checked Zagat ratings to come up with our list. Here are the best restaurants in Westchester County that are also top Zagat Rated Restaurants.

bartaco waterfront restaurant westchester
bartaco restaurant in Port Chester Photo Credit: bartaco

Best Steakhouses in Westchester County

Benjamin Steakhouse– 610 Hartsdale Road, White Plains, NY- (914) 428-6868

Looking for a steakhouse serving top-quality steaks in Westchester? Then you will enjoy Benjamin Steakhouse, owned by two Peter Luger alums, this is a Zagat top-rated steakhouse in White Plains, NY. Benjamin Steakhouse has won numerous awards and is well-known for its outstanding steaks.

Frankie and Johnnie’s Steakhouse– 77 Purchase Street, Rye, NY- (914) 925-3900

Lucky for Westchester, you don’t have to drive to NYC for amazing steak. Frankie and Johnnie’s Steakhouse in Rye is a spin-off of the original Frankie and Johnnie’s Manhattan steakhouses. Head to Frankie and Johnnie’s on Purchase Street in downtown Rye if you’re in the mood for a thick USDA prime dry-aged steak cooked to perfection.

Macelleria Italian Steakhouse– 142 Fifth Avenue, Pelham, NY. (914) 365-2561

One of Westchester County’s top steakhouses is Macelleria Italian Steakhouse in Pelham, NY. Aside from being top zagat rated, Macelleria is also a recipient of the prized Michelin Bib Gourmand award. Macelleria serves some of Westchester County’s best dry-aged USDA prime steaks.

Morton’s Steakhouse- 5 Mamaroneck Avenue, White Plains, NY- (914) 683-6101

You can’t go wrong with the steaks at Morton’s steakhouse, a high-end steakhouse chain. When in Westchester, stop by Morton’s steakhouse in White Plains.

Top Rated Westchester Restaurants serving American Cuisine

105-Ten Bar & Grill– 127 Woodside Avenue, Briarcliff Manor, NY- (914) 236-3651

Craft Beer? Locally Sourced Ingredients? 105-Ten Bar & Grill is an American restaurant offering regionally sourced ingredients in a rustic-industrial space in Westchester’s Briarcliff Manor.

Crabtree’s Kittle House Restaurant and Inn– 11 Kittle Road, Chappaqua, NY- (914) 666-8044

Crabtree’s Kittle House is a Westchester County farm-to-table restaurant that has won numerous awards. It is a top zagat-rated restaurant in Westchester County, set in a lovely historic inn in Chappaqua offering American classics. Enjoy Sunday brunch at Crabtree’s Kittle House Restaurant and Inn and be transported to another era surrounded by the elegant atmosphere.

Lexington Square Cafe– 510 Lexington Avenue, Mt. Kisco, NY (914) 244-3663

Lexington Square Cafe is one of Westchester County’s top Zagat-rated restaurants. This New American restaurant in Mt. Kisco is a must-visit if you’re in the area. This is the place to go if you enjoy seafood. There’s a lot of seafood on the menu, including an entire grilled seafood section. 

Moderne Barn– 430 Bedford Road, Armonk, NY- (914) 730-0001

Moderne Barn is a top-rated restaurant in Westchester County. If you are a fan of the Livanos Family restaurant group (Oceana in NYC, City Limits in White Plains), then you will like Moderne Barn in Armonk. An upscale restaurant serving New American cuisine.

Peter Pratt’s Inn– 673 Croton Heights Road, Yorktown Heights, NY- (914)-962-4090

Peter Pratt’s Inn is one of Westchester County’s best restaurants. Peter Pratt’s Inn is a charming restaurant located in a converted Colonial Barn with roots dating back to 1780 in Yorktown Heights. Serving New American cuisine featuring seasonal fare.

Tredici Social– 104 Kraft Ave, Bronxville, NY. (914) 793-1313

Tredici Social is one of the best restaurants in Westchester County’s Bronxville. Recognized as a Michelin Bib Gourmand restaurant, Tredici Social is known for its New American spin on Italian cuisine. You can’t go wrong with the meatballs. You’ll still be thinking about the food at Tredici Social long after you’ve left the restaurant- it’s that good! 

Best Fine Dining Restaurant in Westchester

X2O Xaviars on the Hudson– 71 Water Grant St., Yonkers, NY- (914) 965-1111

Interview with Chef Peter Kelly
X2O Xaviers on the Hudson

X2O Xaviars on the Hudson is one of the best restaurants in Westchester County. It’s known in Westchester for its classic fine dining and is ideal for date nights. X2O Xaviars on the Hudson, owned by famous chef Peter Kelly, is an award-winning restaurant with spectacular views of the Hudson River.

Check out our interview with Chef Peter Kelly (he reveals in favorite New York restaurants)

Best Italian Restaurants in Westchester

The Cookery– 39 Chestnut Street, Dobbs Ferry, NY- (914) 305-2336

The Cookery is one of the best Italian restaurants in Westchester County. It is a Michelin Bib Gourmand restaurant noted for its outstanding pasta. If you’re in Westchester County’s Rivertown, The Cookery is a must-visit at Dobbs Ferry. David DiBari’s culinary ingenuity will not disappoint.

Lusardi’s– 1885 Palmer Avenue, Larchmont, NY (914) 834-5555

Looking for a good neighborhood Italian restaurant in Larchmont? Definitely try Lusardi’s in Larchmont. This is an upscale Italian restaurant, part of the Mario Fava Restaurant group.

Mima Vinoteca– 63 Main Street, Irvington, NY (914) 591-1300

Looking for an authentic Italian restaurant? Definitely try this cozy Italian restaurant, serving modern Italian restaurant in Westchester’s Irvington, NY.

Moscato– 874 Scarsdale Avenue, Scarsdale, NY- (914) 723-5700

Looking for a high-end Italian-Mediterranean restaurant? Definitely try Moscato, part of the Mario Fava restaurant group, serving Italian-Mediterranean cuisine in Scarsdale, NY.

Rafele Rye– 26 Purchase Street, Rye, NY (914) 481-8417

Rafele Rye is an award-winning restaurant in Westchester County’s Rye. Winner of the coveted Michelin Bib Gourmand Award, Rafele Rye is known for its Neapolitan Italian Cuisine. The homemade pasta dishes are a must-order. 

Rosie’s Bistro Italiano– 10 Palmer Avenue, Bronxville, NY (914) 793-2000

You will feel welcome in Rosie’s Bistro, a bustling Bronxville restaurant frequented by locals. You will enjoy classic Italian dishes like Spaghetti and Meatballs at Rosie’s.

Zuppa– 59 Main Street, Yonkers, NY (914) 376-6500

Zuppa is a trendy, upscale restaurant in Yonkers serving Northern Italian cuisine.

Top Seafood Restaurant in Westchester

Eastchester Fish Gourmet– 837 White Plains Road, Scarsdale, NY- (914) 725-3450

For the freshest seafood in Westchester County, go to Eastchester Fish Gourmet. A popular Scarsdale, New York eatery serving outstanding seafood. Definitely worth a stop for the raw bar and their fresh seafood dishes.

Best French Restaurants in Westchester

La Cremaillere– 49 Bedford-Banksville Road, Bedford, NY- (914) 234-9647

La Crémaillère Restaurant is one of the best classic French restaurants in Westchester County. If you are in the mood for old-school, classic, French cuisine, you can’t go wrong with La Crémaillère Restaurant. Set in a charming farmhouse in Bedford, it’s the perfect setting for a nice intimate dinner.

Red Hat on the River– One Bridge Street, Irvington, NY (914) 591-5888

In Westchester County, Red Hat on the River is a highly rated French-American bistro. At Red Hat on the River, you can’t go wrong with the delicious food and breathtaking Hudson River views. Red Hat on the River is known for its Sunday brunch.

Best Farm to Table Restaurant in Westchester

best restaurants in Westchester
The Inn at Pound Ridge by Jean-Georges

The Inn at Pound Ridge by Jean Georges– 258 Westchester Avenue, Pound Ridge, NY- (914) 764-1400

A Jean-Georges Vongerichten restaurant, serving farm-to-table classics set in a rustic Hudson Valley Inn in Pound Ridge. The Inn at Pound Ridge by Jean Georges is the place to go for brunch. Definitely try their pizzas (get the black truffle pizza), you won’t be disappointed!

Top Zagat Rated Nuevo Latino Restaurant in Westchester

Sonora– 179 Rectory Street, Port Chester, NY (914) 933-0200

Looking for something different? Then stop by Rafael Palomino’s Port Chester restaurant, serving Nuevo Latino cuisine.

Best Mexican Restaurant in Westchester County

El Mocajete– 1506-1508 Westchester Ave., Bronx, NY (914) 688-1433

El Mocajete is an award-winning restaurant in the Bronx (not exactly in Westchester County, but it’s on our list). El Mocajete has been awarded the Michelin Bib Gourmand Award. El Mocajete has some of the best tacos in town!

bartaco– 1 Willet Avenue, Port Chester, NY (914) 937-8226

Bartaco is a popular Mexican restaurant in Westchester County. Known for its Mexican street food. It’s a lively restaurant, you will enjoy dining at a table on the large outdoor patio overlooking Byram River. Get the fish tacos they will not disappoint. 

If you are looking for the best restaurants in Westchester, you should also check for Michelin Rated restaurants in Westchester. Check out our article: Michelin Restaurants in Westchester.

You May Also Be Interested In:

Do you want Restaurant Recommendations from Chefs? Do you know we interview chefs and ask them where they eat on their days off? Check out our column, Eat Where the Chefs Eat: Chef David DiBari’s Favorite Restaurants in Westchester and Chef Peter Kelly’s Favorite Restaurants in Westchester

Best Coffee in Westchester County (according to locals)

Best Pizza in Westchester County (according to locals)

Four Most Authentic Chinese Restaurants in Westchester and Fairfield County

Chef Albert DeAngelis’ Favorite Restaurants in Westchester

About Suburbs 101

Suburbs 101 is an insider’s guide to suburban living. Get the inside scoop on what it’s really like to live in the suburbs through our interviews with local suburbanites and features on Food, Fashion, Home, Garden, Travel, Pets, Real Estate and Local Events. Be sure to Follow Us on Instagram, Like Us on Facebook, Subscribe to our YouTube Channel, and subscribe to our Monthly Newsletter.